Is this antique ring fake? Has the band simply been replaced?

My husband just bought this ring, and it didn't occur to us until after he paid that I've never seen an antique ring with a pink sapphire before. Also, obviously, the price is too good to be true - so we just got excited and jumped on it, thinking it was a perfect birthday gift. But now I'm terrified that he just over-paid for a fake. Could the fact that band is not original to the head account for the low price, or should we try to cancel the payment?


Sorry to hear about your dilemma, but before I get into any details about the issues with this purchase, I would highly recommend cancelling the order asap.

I removed the link to protect the privacy of the seller, but here are some major red flags about the seller/shop the ring was purchased from:

1. The rings in her store are WAY under-priced. There is no way that these rings can be authentic antique or vintage rings. Even replicas made with mid-quality materials are priced much higher than the rings she has listed.

2. The seller has no experience what-so-ever with antique or vintage rings, and really hardly any experience with jewelry. Her only experience listed is an interest in gems and jewelry as a hobby. She also mentions that a family member was a jeweler but then contradicts this statement by saying her family member was just a designer.

3. She says that all her pieces have been authenticated by a jeweler/gemologist, but none of the pieces that I've seen listed in her shop come with a certificate of authentication. Authenticating pieces of jewelry, especially antique and vintage rings, takes time and expertise - and certified gemologist/jewelers charge for this service...and provide a written report of their findings. But again, there is no mention of who authenticated the pieces and no verification provided to the buyers that the pieces were actually authenticated by a knowledgeable, certified gemologist - and no proof that the rings were authenticated at all.

4. All of her sales are final - unless the items turn out to be not as they were described (which is another red flag, why would this policy even be mentioned if the rings have been authenticated). She does not offer any type of refund at all.

Now for issues with the ring itself:

1. The ring is in awful, truly horrendous, condition. I doubt if the ring could even be worn for any period of time before completely falling apart.

2. As you mentioned, the ring is not an original piece. It looks like a band from another ring was soldered to the setting with what can only be described as way-below-standard soldering workmanship. It's just terrible.

3. This ring, as with her other rings listed, does not come with a certificate of authentication.

4. In the listing for the ring, she mentions, "This ring is very old. The setting is in silver on a 14k gold band. It is from either the 1700s or 1800s. True age is unknown."
In other words - she has no idea when the ring was made. Dating a ring to the "1700s or 1800s" is a huge jump. We're talking about a vast difference in design eras covering a span of over one hundred years - not to mention possible historical significance. She also does not mention why she believes the ring is old or why she dated it to the 1700s or 1800s.
*As an aside too, she wrote "The ring is very old" when she should have said, "I believe the pieces that have been melded together to create this ring are very old."

5. She mentioned that the ring is surrounded by 8 small rose cut diamonds of various sizes, but again offers no evidence as to why she believes the diamonds are real and not, say, paste or even white sapphires.

6. Pink gemstones were very popular during the Victorian age, and to some extent during the Georgian age too. It is common to see Victorian rings made with light pink colored rubies, pink tourmaline, light garnet and even pink sapphires. (Though the use of rubies and garnet were more common than the use of pink sapphires).

*So, antique rings can be made with pink sapphires as they were available for crafted jewelry even as far back as the 1500s - but a man-made gemstone known as "Strass" was a very popular material used throughout the Georgian and Victorian years too. Strass is basically lead glass, and was used to create brilliant paste gemstones with a high degree of sparkle and flash. Bright pink Strass was made too - and often used to imitate the more expensive ruby, tourmaline and sapphire gemstones. Synthetic gemstones - including ruby and sapphires - were available during the Victorian period as well.

Bottom line?

The ring is in terrible condition, it is not even one original piece, there is no proof that the materials in the ring have been authenticated, there is no evidence provided as to why the ring is believed to be antique and the person selling the ring has no experience in the antique jewelry market. And the seller offers no refund with her wares - when jewelers stand behind their products, they always offer some types of refund, even a 7 day refund, or - in the case of bespoke or custom rings - an exchange guarantee of some type.

Honestly, I get so frustrated when I see these kinds of so called antique or vintage shops online. Whether intentionally or not, the people who run these shops - who have no clue about antique or vintage jewelry - are taking advantage of people who truly love vintage and antique jewelry pieces and who may be searching for a bargain.

At any rate, please try to return the ring as quickly as possible. Even if the pieces the ring are made with are antique, they would only be used for scrap because of their horrible condition. In this case, you overpaid for what you believed was a pretty good deal. (And looking at the other pieces in her shop, I can see why potential customers would be fooled because some of her rings look quite nice - but of course they are priced way too low and are most likely cheap imitations).

If you are looking for antique rings online, three places I highly recommend include:

Brilliant Earth - In addition to handcrafted engagement and wedding rings, BE maintains a huge selection of genuine certified antique and vintage rings, and some are in the under $1,000 dollar price range. BE offers sizing too on all rings.

Turtle Love - if you would like to find an affordable vintage ring, Turtle Love is the perfect shop. TL carries a limited selection of real unique vintage rings - most from around the 1950s Retro period and some from the late Art Deco years - and many of their rings are in the $500 to $1,000 dollar price range. All rings at TL too are examined and authenticated by professional jewelers and can be resized.

Adin Fine Antique Jewelry - Adin carries a breathtaking selection of antique, vintage and estate rings. Plus, when possible, Adin offers free ring sizing services too. While you'll find a lot of high-end antique rings here, there is also a smaller selection of affordable antique rings - all which come with a certificate of authentication. And, you can receive an additional 5% off any Adin purchase by using the code: Everything-Wedding-Rings when you checkout!

Here are a few rings which are currently available at Adin for very affordable prices that you might be interested in:

1. Victorian 18k red gold, 3-stone crossover ring with rubies, pearls and a mine cut diamond - $435

2. Victorian diamond ring, silver on 18k gold with rose cut diamonds - $435

3. French Victorian 18k gold and platinum rose cut diamond ring - $622

I sincerely hope that you will be able to return the ring for a full and prompt refund. Please keep us posted with how everything turns out - and thank you for sending in your question. While this shopping experience has not been a positive one for you, hopefully future visitors who read this page will find the information useful for locating their own authentic antique rings.

Best of luck with your refund!

Suzanne Gardner
Everything Wedding Rings

Comments for Is this antique ring fake? Has the band simply been replaced?

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

by: Suzanne Gardner - Everything Wedding Rings

P.S. I just wanted add one more thing. After I replied to your question I was browsing through the seller's selection of rings - many were listed as "antique" without even an estimated date of their origin provided - and I noticed on one picture that a ring was resting inside a case that was inside a jewelry ring box with the company name "Elizabeth Duke" stamped on it. Elizabeth Duke is a jewelry company that was started in the early 1980s and was famous for making cheap and sometimes gaudy - also known as "chavy" - imitation jewelry pieces which rarely exceeded 9 karat gold, ED also made imitation vintage rings too. The Elizabeth Duke brand is no longer in existence (the giant retailer Argo opened the ED brand and then closed it down a few years ago) but ED pieces can be found on Etsy and eBay for around $20 to $40 dollars. I'm wondering now if some of these rings are really vintage-style Elizabeth Duke rings that were dramatically marked up and then sold as real antique or vintage rings.

Additional updates?
by: Shari D

My goodness!! It surely sounds like this transaction, and that vendor's merchandise, are really a disaster waiting to happen! As I read through your response to this writer's experience, I was more and more horrified! I can't imagine any vendor with such an incredible lack of knowledge and experience in the field in which she has decided to involve herself lasting for very long. At least not with any degree of financial success over any period of time.
I feel bad for the purchaser who wrote to you originally, for having found themselves in such a dilemma. Did you ever hear anything further from them regarding any refund or other resolution to their original plight? I'd be so intrigued by any further information this situation developed following your original reply!
And, I do understand why you deleted the vendor's identity from the original post, but in a way, it's a shame that you can't reveal it in order to warn others away from the very financially dangerous possibility of any future transactions!


Hi Shari,
I never did hear an update from this situation, but this is why it is so important to only purchase antique or vintage rings from retailers that 1). Have verifiable experience dealing with these types of rings, 2). Sell their rings with an authentication form, 3). Offer a guarantee on the rings they sell.
I receive at least 15 emails a week asking if a an antique ring is real after the ring has already been purchased - if you are purchasing from a verifiable retailer, there is no reason to ever ask this question!!! Thank-you for your comment, hopefully it will help more people to think twice before purchasing a ring and then asking if it is 'really real' after the purchase.

Suzanne Gardner
Everything Wedding Rings

Click here to add your own comments

Click here to return to Antique Wedding Rings.